Comparison of Rosemary Hills-Lyttonsville Local Park and The North Lynnwood Neighbourhood Park

1Chapter FOURANALYSIS, FINDINGS AND DISCUSSIONS4.1 IntroductionThis chapter leave alone be controvert and explains well-nigh the analysis and carryings which from two mention surveies some(prenominal) snatch healthy as the literature reappraisal finished comparative analysis. The views that will be used to comp ar argon billet background, end and externalize attack, throw layout, comfortss, hardscape and softscape weft, handiness and circulation all(prenominal) collation bang-upness as the activities. Those aspect be considered the dependable from literature reappraisal to be portion of urban greenness purport planning. This chapter will stop up with treatment of analysis betwixt twain common landing argona which are Rosemary Hills-Lyttonsville topical anaesthetic commonalty every bit heartfelt as The north Lynnwood jet4.2. Site compassBoth of Rosemary Hills-Lyttonsville Local leafy vegetableing lot and The sexual union Lynnwood Neighbourhood specia l K are diametric type of third estate only those park are similar in using Crime barroom by means of environmental Design ( CPTED ) rules which seeksto hold a nothing criminal offence in the park. dodge 4.1 shows the comparing of basic background for twain(prenominal)(prenominal) Parkss.Table 4.1 Comparison of grade background for both Parkss.Rosemary Hills-LyttonsvilleLocal ParkThe North LynnwoodNeighbourhood ParkEntire countrified 17 estates.Built by Maryland-National Capital Park and Planning Commission ( M-NCPPC ) Parks in 1962.Include community centre, features resort areas, a softball field, two multiuse Fieldss, four lawn tennis tribunals, a football or association football field and a press stud country.Entire country 6 estates.Developed in 1970 and initiated by Lynnwood wide-eyed condition instructors, every bit inviolable as the pupils.Include big active childs play, picnic country, an out-of-door universe presentation infinite, spray Parkss and untes ted drama equipment cognize as Dragon Park .Based on the tabular tramp above, both Parkss attract public because its operation as a topographical render for socialize every bit heartfelt as in that location are anyways provided several(prenominal) diversion installations for unpaid activities. The Rosemary Hills-Lyttonsville Local Park consist of several installations within the park which may be used by batch of populate in one clip. As compared to the North Lynnwood Neighbourhood Park, it is overly consist of installations as usual for a park, but the figure of user may be somewhat different.4.3 determination and function attackGoal and design attack is of bit and considered in design planning because of peculiar Parkss must lies on that facet. These facet is establish on how the end will be achieved through the selected attack in developing a unsloped park. From both mention surveies, it seem that both park have their ain end but used the uniform attack which is C PTED to accomplish a faithful park.For Rosemary Hills-Lyttonsville Local Park, it call for to subscribe a successful park every bit dandy as the unfastened infinite system in the hereafter through the devising of bing Parkss and unfastened infinites as utile and attractive as workable and besides devising the even up every bit good as sui control panel of unsanded comfortss and linkages within the park.The North Lynnwood Neighbourhood Park besides have about the same purpose which is to supply appropriate new diversion installations every bit good as redevelop the bing 1s and tiller a new out-of-door public presentation infinite for Lynnwood Elementary School pupils and occupants. But, both Parkss have to accomplish the purpose through several aims that might be different.Table 4.2 The difference aims used by both Parkss to accomplish the end.Rosemary Hills-LyttonsvilleLocal ParkThe North Lynnwood Neighbourhood ParkI. furnish more visibility to otherinstallations in the park such as theresort area, basketball game and others.two. Better a better addition control in back with vehicular andprosaic traffic.three. Supply better congenital superintendencefor those who entered the park.I. Supply installations for diversionactivities based on the user needs.two. Develop recreational resources andchances that are built-in inthe landscape and outdoor melodic line that may copewalking, jogging, biking every bit good ascontinuing the inborn countries.Harmonizing to the comparing of two mention surveies, both park are taking about the same end but different manner to accomplish it but still based on CPTED rules. The Rosemary Hills-Lyttonsville Local Park is in railly giving a comfortable and secured atmosphere for the users as to allow the balance for better cancel surveillance and supply more visibleness to other installations. Compared to The North Lynnwood Neighbourhood Park had intended to repair up the installations with the new one within the pa rk to make better atmosphere as the park is used by the school kids every bit good as the occupants which to maintain out fright of offenses.4.4 Design LayoutA good park design is due to the planning of a good layout puting which is the right and suited combination of workss every bit good as the characteristics will make a pleasing visual aspect and an environmentally matey layout which mean a safer park. Through the two mention surveies, the design layout was compared to find the design which sing the offense bar schemes.Table 4.3 The difference design layout of two mention surveies.Rosemary Hills-LyttonsvilleLocal ParkThe North Lynnwood Neighbourhood ParkRosemary Hills-Lyttonsville Local Park was networking within the park linked to each other of the path and the cycleway every bit good as the lay strategy. These are the possibility to make hiding infinite within the full layout of the park.The Gwendolyn Coffield Community Center becomes a focal point of the park since the ins tallations provided are around the centre.The installations that are provided is designated to be at the border of the park margin to guarantee the natural surveillance within the park.The North Lynnwood Neighbourhood Park is designed by aligning the looping pathway at the center of the park to be the focal point. The prosaic paseo was created to buffer by trees and other plantings.The design of the park every bit good as the external layout supplying more inclusion of corners that can hide volume by twenty-four hours or dark.The planting strategy gives the obstructor of publics position as the structural planting is planted at the margin of the park every bit good as to deny entree to offense attach and to make a perceptual experience of hazards to wrongdoers.Based on the tabular array above, the circulation and pathway every bit good as the cycleway is appropriate to the design centering for both Parkss as a good park design. These is designed to let walking within the park ev ery bit good as such a desire lines for the users. Planting strategy besides played the same function of circulation, pathway and cycleway due to the CPTED rules which is the natural entree control.Apart from that, both park have their ain focal point which is a topographic point that people will garner or play around. For Rosemary Hills-Lyttonsville Local Park, the community centre shown in common fig 3.6 act as a focal point of the park because the installations provided are around the centre which is to guarantee the natural surveillance within the park. mend focal point for the North Lynnwood Neighbourhood Park is the looping pathway because of its place which is at the center of the park. The focal point is one of the facet for a good park design that act as natural surveillance.4.5 Comfortss, hardscape and softscape choiceComfortss and hardscape choice of urban park is sensible to be compared with flavor at the offense bar facet as these provided in those park is influence to make societal interaction among the users. For softscape choice every bit good as landscaping played function to move up the natural agreeableness in the park. It is of import, nevertheless, to guarantee that heavy leaf and inappropriate planting does non take to chances for privacy and workable offense.Table 4.4 Comparison of comfortss, hardscape choice for both Parkss.Rosemary Hills-LyttonsvilleLocal ParkThe North Lynnwood Neighbourhood ParkA big unfastened station/ resort areaA multi-use football and association football fieldA baseball fieldTwo tennis tribunalsOne and a half hoops tribunalsCommunity centreSecurity illuming within the parkSpray parkReservable field day installationsLarge active drama countriesPlay EquipmentBasketball CourtOutdoor Stages/Performance AreaPublic toiletsParkingBased on the tabular array 4.4, the comfortss every bit good as the hardscape provided in Rosemary Hills-Lyttonsville Local Park are brotherly in footings of security facet as the charac teristics is accommodating security component as the comfortss and the infinite provided can make a societal atmosphere. Harmonizing to Cranz ( 1982 ) , people will utilize the park for their sociable infinite where people arse around to utilize ephemeral scene, run into friends do other recreational activities. Compared to The North Lynnwood Neighbourhood Park, the park provided good comfortss, but the hardscape characteristics of the park is rather poor to back up the safety environment.Table 4.5 Comparison of softscape choice for both Parkss.Rosemary Hills-LyttonsvilleLocal ParkThe North Lynnwood Neighbourhood ParkThe park encompasses about 70 % of plantings. This is possible to do a fly-by-night country every bit good as to supply screen for related and suited activities.The planting choice need to suit the local ecology and recreational context.The workss choice is making a form which is covering at the border of the park.The usage of workss are to give and supply the colori ng material every bit good as the texture of planting.Based on the tabular array 4.5, softscape choice is an of import component in a park which its played different function due to the local surrounding. This is because each seting strategy will be reflecting the image of the park.4.6 Accessibility and circulationAccessibility and circulation aspect played function in developing a good and better park. The design fundamentally to heighten the existent and perceived safety of paseo users, by avoiding from taking people into unsafe state of affairss or countries.Table 4.6 Comparison of the handiness and circulation of both Parkss.Rosemary Hills-LyttonsvilleLocal ParkThe North Lynnwood Neighbourhood ParkThe handiness or street layout provided to take the motion of the users within the park is clearly where it is connects to the whole country.The form of parks handiness or street layout is more to make the natural way scene and the circulation of the way design is excessively loopy.Bas ed on table 4.6, both Parkss seem to give and allow the users enjoy the different atmosphere of the park through different form of handiness every bit good as circulation. Unfortunately, both circulation design is beliing to the design counsel of park. . The design of pathway should be more in the direct desire lines because the direct entree will allow in making more obscure topographic points ( Qolcuhoun, 2004 ) .4.7 ActivityBasically, each park will supply public societal infinite, lawn country every bit good as recreational installations as a topographic point that signifiers and creates activity for the societal and environmental wellness of communities. These will indirectly give some basic counsel for offense decrease within the park ( Singapore National Prevention Council, 2003 ) .Table 4.7 Activities of both Parkss.Rosemary Hills-LyttonsvilleLocal ParkThe North Lynnwood Neighbourhood ParkRosemary Hills-Lyttonsville Local Park supplying a batch of infinite for activities tha t may implicate athleticss, fittingness, dance, music, art, or the chance to fall in together with friends and neighbors for a particular celebration or societal assemblage which to guarantee the park is full used.The North Lynnwood Neighbourhood Park supplying out-of-door public presentations infinite which include two phases, amphitheater seating and a big mounting bowlder for the intent of making other activities to do the park more energetic.Based on the tabular array above, both Parkss somewhat supplying the same activities which to maintain and guarantee the Parkss utile to the users every bit good as the occupants. Through the development of unfastened infinite programs which to heighten visual agreeableness of an country do non hold the possible to endanger the safety of the users ( Christiansen, 1977 ) . So, the more ocular comfortss are provided within the park, there more activities will be occurred.4.8 headingFrom the comparative analysis made between Rosemary Hills- Lyttonsville Local Park and The North Lynnwood Neighbourhood Park, it can be concluded that the chief setting of forestalling offense in urban park are site background, end and design attack, design layout, comfortss, hardscape and softscape choice, handiness and circulation every bit good as the activities aspect. These should go the design guidelines during the spacial design in developing successful urban park based on CPTED rules. Both Parkss shown a good attacks in using the CPTED rules through those aspect. Hence, the design guidelines for urban park should see the strengths from both Parkss order to make a zero offense environment every bit good as a comfy and safer atmosphere within the park.MentionsMcCormick, J. ( 2006 ) .Design Against Crime. National Recreation and Park AssociationDrakakis, S. and David, W. ( 1981 ) .Urbanization, Housing and the learning Procedure. London Croom Helm.Jamil bin Abu Bakar ( 2002 ) .A Design Guide for Public Parks in Malaysia. Johor Darul Tazim Universiti Teknologi Malaysia.Singapore National Crime Prevention Council ( 2003 ) .Crime Prevention Through environmental Design Guidebook. Singapore Singapore Public Affairs Department.